Connect with us


Goodbye New Jersey, Hello New York: The Carmelo Saga

This article was written by Double G Sports Contributing Writer, Alan McPhaul III

Ohh where ohh where will Carmelo go, ohh where ohh where will he be?

The countdown is on, Carmelo Anthony is either coming to New York or New Jersey. Carmelo does not want to be a Denver Nugget anymore, and wants to be in the New York area so he can be close to his wife, La La.

The Denver Nuggets are in a tough spot because they could keep him through the rest of the season; however, they would not receive any compensation for his departure. The move they are looking to make is to trade him, which is the only move to make. But where would he land?

I am a fan of no NBA team but I am a huge NBA fan. I am glad that the New York Knicks are finally having some success since the departure of Patrick Ewing, and the idea of Carmelo coming to New York even excites a native of New Jersey like me. Sure Carmelo went to school in Syracuse, the beloved basketball school of many New Yorkers; and if Carmelo came to the Garden, he probably would sell out the arena night in and night out.

However, I know many of you Knick fans are going to hate me for saying this, but Carmelo Anthony is not a good fit in New York. I mean if it isn’t broke don’t fix it.

The New York Knicks are an astounding 22-15, only 7 games behind the Eastern Conference leader. They have a big name in Amare Stoudemire, who is 2nd in the NBA in scoring with 26.2 points per game (Kevin Durant is 1st and Carmelo is 9th). They have a plethora of young talent such as Laundry Fields, Danilo Gallinari, and Toney Douglas, and they have great role players in Raymond Felton, Wilson Chandler, and Ronny Turiaf.

I might have to take the role player title off of Chandler and Felton because both of those players are fitting real well with the system the Knicks are running right now and look like all-stars. Any trade they would have to put on the table for Melo would mess up the team chemistry, and potentially be disastrous for such a spectacular start for the New York Knicks. 

Now the New Jersey Nets are 10-27, basically beyond struggling. The Nets have a lot of young players and draft picks they could get rid of in the supposed 15 player trade to land Carmelo which wouldn’t hurt the team at all. I mean how much worse can it get?

Although it is too late to turn their season around, it is never too late to sell tickets. Fans of the Nets want to see something more than Brooke Lopez and Devin Harris. Sure both of those players are pretty good talents, but the Nets are plain boring plus losing which equals a double negative. That means it’s positive right? Negative. They need Carmelo to at least bring some excitement back to the fans and the Prudential Center.  

Carmelo appears to be too costly for the Knicks to gamble on, so the Nets seem to be the winners of his talents. The bad news for the Nets is that it does seem Melo would be hesitant to sign an extension with the sinking ship. This would leave Melo open next season to sign with the Knicks.

For Nets fans, I guess the glass is half full or half empty depending on how you look at it because at least you would have his services for half a season. Half is better than zero!

The Knicks are making the playoffs this year, but I doubt they will win the NBA championship. If Melo does sign with the Nets without the extension, next season it very well could be, goodbye New Jersey, hello New York, and a championship might grace the big apple once again.



  1. Pingback: Goodbye New Jersey, Hello New York: The Carmelo Saga, NBA | BallHyped Sports Blogs

  2. Pingback: Carmelo Anthony Rumors: Goodbye, New Jersey and Hello, New York |

  3. Avatar


    January 13, 2011 at 9:52 am

    I don’t understand? First you say that Carmello isn’t a good fit for the Knicks, and then you end the story by saying that if Carmello signs with the Knicks….they most likely will win a championship? What exactly are you trying to tell us in this article??

  4. Avatar


    January 13, 2011 at 2:10 pm

    Larry, this is Alan the writer of the article, and you are right; I should have specified more. Melo is such a great talent he would make any team better but the Knicks are playing real good team ball. With a player like Melo, he would change the whole game plan for the team. Mid-season with such a great record, the Knicks would have to give up their core of good players that are fitting well with Coach D’Antonio’s system and they would have to try to make it work on the fly. Granted it could work, but why gamble with something going well. Now if they wait, and Melo does become a free agent and sign with the Knicks; they have all offseason to make it work and make him fit into a system. They have more time to play around and figure it out. The Knicks struggled in the beginning of the season and look like a well oiled machine. No need to through kinks into now, if you know what I mean. But with the talent they have now, without giving up anyone, and add Melo, with the offseason to make it work, the New York Knicks might be the favorites in the East.

    • Avatar


      January 14, 2011 at 11:44 am

      Alan….the Knicks need to get Carmello to make them an elite team capable of winning a title…the players that they have now have made them a much impoved team, but with Carmello they are an ELITE team…Chandler, Gallo and Landry are nice players, but they are replaceable…Carmello is a unique talent and made for the big-stage…..Amare, Carmello and Felton running the floor would set the Garden on fire….They need Carmello and must do ANYTHING to get him……….

  5. Avatar


    January 13, 2011 at 2:15 pm

    Sorry typing fast in last post, two quick edits: I meant they were struggling last year but *now are a well oiled machine.

    And no need to *throw kinks into it now

    By the way, thank you for reading my article and commenting. It is much appreciated.

  6. Pingback: Tweets that mention Goodbye New Jersey, Hello New York: The Carmelo Saga | Double G Sports --

  7. Avatar


    January 18, 2011 at 8:23 am


    This is Alan the writer of the article.
    I agree to a certain extent. Look at the talent they have in Denver. Granted, they don’t have an Amare Stoudemire teamed with Carmelo but they do have Nene and Keyon Martin to go with Billups and J.R. Smith. Sure they aren’t the Knicks but Carmelo couldn’t get over the hump with the Nuggets, he would make the Knicks better on paper, I doubt it would be worth getting rid of those so called expendable players. Talent is one thing and chemistry is another. And I think the Knicks right now do not need to get rid of any of the chemistry they have going for them, especially if they have a chance to get Carmelo for nothing at the end of the season.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


If sports resumed with fans this summer - would you attend a game?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

Email Format


Photo of the Month

Photo of the Month

(Photo by Danny Suriel)

More in Basketball