Connect with us


Why getting rid of Joe Girardi hurt the Yankees more than it helped

As we all know, the New York Yankees decided this fall after a very nice playoff run that Joe Girardi will not be the manager of the team anymore.

During the playoffs, specifically during the ALDS series there was a lot of criticism towards the former Yankees manager. Specifically on his decision not to challenge a play that ultimately led to an Indians rally which then cost the Yankees the game. This was no doubt a bad decision by Girardi, and many Yankees fans then had it out for him. Girardi’s team still fought hard and made it to the ALCS and ended up falling one win short of the World Series. An obvious, over achievement for the young team.

Girardi did one thing that stood out while he was the manager, win. Girardi led his teams to a 910-710 regular season record. That’s 200 games over .500 and that’s really good last time I checked.

But, Girardi also did many other things well during his time at the head. To start, Girardi was a guy who knows New York. Not every single person in the world of sports can play or coach in New York and that’s just a reality, Girardi was a guy who could. Girardi also showed he was able to coach under high expectations. For example, in 2009 the Yankees were one of the favorites to take home the trophy and he was able to get his team to win it when it was all said and done. Girardi clearly showed he had the players fighting for him. They were able to come back and win after they were down 0-2 to the Indians. These players easily could’ve thrown in the towel like some other New York teams we know.

I also believe Girardi deserved to stay simply because he was the best option for this team. There’s truly not a better option then Giardi out there. It’s not like the Yankees are going to hire Terry Francona or Joe Maddon. They’re simply going to have to bring in an unproven manager.

In the end, I don’t believe the Yankeees made the right move here. They won’t be getting something better than what they had. This may really hurt the team. This seems to be more of a move made out of spite than a strategical move.

Latest posts by Jimmy Cody (see all)



    1. Gerald Mullins

      November 11, 2017 at 9:52 am

      I’m with you on this. It makes no sense what so ever. The lack of communication lies on Cashman. Did he speak with Girardi on these supposed issues. I doubt it. Where is this scary great manager that is better than Girardi? Maybe hasn’t even been born yet. There is no perfect manager and it took Cashman 10 years to decide Girardi doesn’t communicate good with young players. And lastly you can’t please everyone.

      • Kate Conroy

        November 24, 2017 at 4:12 pm

        Girardi won National League Manager of the Year in 2006 with the Florida Marlins and that team was post a fire sale so it was all minor league players, literally. So how Joe doesn’t connect with the players is hard to believe, especially since this season was supposed to be a rebuild that turned out a game from a World Series. This is all about the Benjamins….and Hal being cheap. FYI…Eric Wedge is not coming because he will command a $2.5-$4 million so about $2-$3 million less the Joe but still to high for Hal.

      • Kate Conroy

        November 24, 2017 at 4:14 pm

        One more point is that if “communicating well” is being based off Gary Sanchez….the Yanks are in trouble.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Photo of the Month

    Photo of the Month

    (Photo by Brandon Koodish - Double G Media)


    Who should Giants take No. 2 in NFL Draft?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...


    More in Baseball